Quick Guide Incorporating Peer Review Feedback

An Example

Below is an example of revisions made to address reviewer comments for a book on abstract mathematics.

Reviewer Comments

Reviewer A: I would have liked something in the introduction that explains what is new and different in the 2nd edition. I would prefer a different example on p. 204 so you don’t have to talk about couples dancing and assume one man and one woman in each couple.

Author Response/Revision Plan

We are incorporating the reviewer’s suggestions to amend the Introduction to note the changes from the first edition, and we also changed the paragraph about the dancers and couples (now it’s about nuts and bolts; hence the photo addition).

The Manuscript Before Peer Review

Alt Text

The Manuscript after Peer Review

Alt Text

Unsure of next steps or have additional questions? Ask your project editor!